• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
Hurt on the Job? Call Bob in AZ

Hurt on the Job? Call Bob in AZ

"Justice for the injured worker"

Compensación al trabajador > EnglishSpanish
602-234-3700
Call Today For A Free Initial Consultation
  • About Us
    • Attorneys
    • Meet the staff
    • Community
  • Workers’ Compensation
    • Benefits for injured workers
    • Am I eligible to apply?
    • My claim was denied.
    • Is PTSD covered?
    • Workers’ compensation guide
  • Work injuries
    • Back injury at work
    • Car accidents
    • Truck accidents
    • Traumatic brain injury
    • Shoulder injury
    • Slip and fall
    • View all
  • We Represent
    • Firefighters
    • Police
    • Paramedics
    • Professional Athletes
    • View all
  • Resources
    • Blog
    • Reviews
    • Videos
  • FAQ
  • Contact

Is Horseplay At Work Covered By Arizona Workers’ Compensation?

Hurt on the Job? Call Bob, Arizona Work Injury Lawyer
phone icon (602) 234-3700 Schedule an Appointment
Phoenix Job Injury Attorney (Home) > Blog > Workers' Comp 101 > Is Horseplay At Work Covered By Arizona Workers’ Compensation?

October 15, 2019

Horseplay isn’t an unusual activity at work. At times, it can even be beneficial for employees to engage in some play, which creates a comradery.

However, sometimes horseplay goes too far and somebody gets hurt.

If someone is injured while engaging in horseplay at work, they can still file a workers’ compensation claim unless it constitutes a “substantial deviation” which effectively “abandons” employment, as ruled in Jaimes v. Industrial Commission of Arizona , 787 P.2d 1103, 163 Ariz. 307 (Ariz. App., 1990).

The test laid out in the Jaimes case states:

“Whether initiation of horseplay is a deviation from course of employment depends on, the extent and seriousness of the deviation, (2) the completeness of the deviation (ie., whether it was commingled with the performance of duty or involved an abandonment of duty), (3) the extent to which the practice of horseplay had become an accepted part of the employment, and (4) the extent to which the nature of the employment may be expected to include some such horseplay.”
(Id. at 309, 787 P.2d at 1105)

In the Jaimes case, the injured worker (Claimant) was riding a three-wheeled utility cart for transporting equipment and personnel on the usual path to the fourth tee of a golf course where he worked as a maintenance person. Two other co-workers were sitting on the two seats and the Claimant was seated on the dash facing the other co-workers.

There was some conflicting testimony regarding whether the Claimant tickled the driver of the cart. Ultimately, the Claimant ended up falling off the cart and was run over, sustaining serious injuries.

The Court held that the Claimant didn’t substantially deviate from his employment. (Id at 307, 787 P.2d 1103)

In the courts’ analysis, they conclude that the extent and seriousness of the deviation wasn’t substantial. This ruling doesn’t pertain to the seriousness of the injuries, but rather the extent of the work departure caused by horseplay.

The horseplay occurred during work-related travel, commingled with the performance of a duty. The Claimant had not abandoned his employment by riding on the cart.

Additionally, the nature of the employment could be expected to include some horseplay because crowding three workers onto a small golf cart was conducive to horseplay, the Court said.

Moreover, to a certain degree the activity was accepted by the employer because the Claimant was never warned not to ride on the dashboard of the cart although other workers were warned. (Id at 310, 787 P.2d at 1106)

What does this mean for your workers’ compensation case?

In conclusion, you may still have a compensable claim if you were engaging in horseplay on the job. However, it will depend on a variety of factors.

Each of these types of cases will be decided based on the totality and degree of these elements such as whether it was common and accepted to engage in certain types of horseplay, whether the horseplay would be characteristic of the work, and if the extent the deviation was substantial and effectively constitutes abandonment of the job.

If your claim is denied, contact us and we can provide you a free consultation regarding the facts and strengths of your case.

Related resources

  • Arizona Workers’ Compensation for Home Depot Employees
    Arizona Workers’ Compensation for Home Depot Employees
  • Arizona Workers’ Compensation & Failed Drug Tests: What Happens Now?
    Arizona Workers’ Compensation & Failed Drug Tests:…
  • Arizona Workplace Electrical Accidents & Injuries
    Arizona Workplace Electrical Accidents & Injuries
5-star review image
Unmatched Dedication
Workers Compensation  |  Phoenix
Unmatched Dedication
2019-07-16
"Mr. Wisniewski is the best lawyer that I have ever had the pleasure of working with and knowing. ..."
N.A., Verified Customer
5-star review image
Thank You for All These Years of Service
Workers Compensation  |  Phoenix
Thank You for All These Years of Service
2019-07-16
"Dear Bob, thank you for all these years of service. I don’t know what I would have ..."
D.W.T., Verified Customer
5-star review image
You won't be disappointed
Workers Compensation  |  Phoenix
Workers' compensation claim
2020-02-12
"I hired Robert Wisniewski for my workers compensation claim. The Law Offices of Robert Wisniewski has been excellent ..."
J.R., Verified Customer

Primary Sidebar

Categories

  • Community
  • Firm News
  • Work Injuries & Illnesses
  • Workers' Comp 101
  • Workers' Comp FAQs
  • Workplace Safety Tips

Recent Posts

  • Arizona Grocery Store Workers Report Mental Health Struggles from COVID-19
  • CDC Study Suggest Further Protections Needed for Minor Workers
  • What To Do in Arizona if You Contract COVID-19 At Work
  • The Erosion of Workers’ Comp Benefits
    in America

Footer

DISCUSS YOUR CASE WITH AN EXPERIENCED WORKERS' COMPENSATION LAWYER TODAY

CALL: (602) 234-3700
TOLL FREE IN AZ: (800) 224-3220
FAX: (602) 230-7579

Law Office Locations

Phoenix

519 E Thomas Rd
Phoenix, AZ 85012
Map and Directions

Yuma

1455 W. 16th Street A2
Yuma, AZ 85364
Map and Directions

Kingman

2601 Stockton Hill Rd, Suite H-8
Kingman, AZ 86401
Map and Directions

    Get started with a free consultation



    Disclaimer: If you are not a current client of Law Offices of Robert E Wisniewski, PC, sending him or this site an email will not create an attorney/client relationship and the information you send may not be maintained as confidential. Please contact Mr. Wisniewski's office by telephone to arrange a consultation or complete a Consultation Intake Form. Viewing this website information also does not create an attorney/client relationship. This website is governed by the Arizona Rules of Professional Conduct.

    I have read the disclaimer. *
    Privacy Policy

    © 2021 Law Offices of Robert E. Wisniewski. All rights reserved. Disclaimer | Site Map | Law Firm Online Marketing by SEO Advantage, Inc.

    Part of the Enjuris Network

    • Facebook icon
    • Twitter icon
    • LinkedIn icon
    • Youtube icon