• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
Hurt on the Job? Call Bob in AZ

Hurt on the Job? Call Bob in AZ

"Justice for the injured worker"

602-234-3700
Call Today For A Free Initial Consultation
  • About Us
    • Attorneys
    • Meet the staff
    • Community
  • Workers’ Compensation
    • Benefits for injured workers
    • Am I eligible to apply?
    • My claim was denied.
    • Is PTSD covered?
    • Workers’ compensation guide
  • Work injuries
    • Back injury at work
    • Car accidents
    • Truck accidents
    • Traumatic brain injury
    • Shoulder injury
    • Slip and fall
    • View all
  • We Represent
    • Firefighters
    • Police
    • Paramedics
    • Professional Athletes
    • View all
  • Resources
    • Blog
    • Free Workers’ Comp E-book
    • Reviews
    • Videos
    • Scholarships
  • FAQ
  • Contact

The Law Offices of Robert E. Wisniewski Scholarship Winner: Insurance Surveillance of Injured Workers

Hurt on the Job? Call Bob, Arizona Work Injury Lawyer
phone icon (602) 234-3700 Schedule an Appointment
Phoenix Job Injury Attorney (Home) > Blog > Firm News > The Law Offices of Robert E. Wisniewski Scholarship Winner: Insurance Surveillance of Injured Workers

August 30, 2022

Robert E. Wisniewski was a student while also serving in the United States Air Force. So he understands that obtaining your degree can be stressful and requires determination and skill.

In order to help students across the country reach their collegiate goals, the Law Offices of Robert E. Wisniewski offered its first $1,000 scholarship to the student who could write the best essay on the topic:

Do you agree that insurance companies should legally be able to obtain surveillance of injured workers as part of a settlement investigation? Why or why not?

After reviewing the submissions, we’re pleased to announce the winner—Shaela Hayes from the University of Cincinnati.

Here’s her winning essay:

Business models for insurance companies are simple: bring in more revenue than payouts. Apart from accurate risk assessments, insurance companies ensure success by making sure they only pay worker’s compensation benefits to those who are actually injured. But how is this done? Though a surprise to most, insurance companies can legally obtain surveillance of injured workers as part of settlement investigations. While this doesn’t mean that insurance companies can bug your house or camp out in your car, what they can do feels eerily similar. Under Arizona law, insurance companies can hire private investigators to surveil you anywhere that is not a private location. This means you can be watched in public parks, grocery stores, shopping malls, and even your sidewalk. Less surprising in our technology driven-world today, an investigator’s realm of surveilling also includes your online presence: Facebook, Instagram, Twitter, and your embarrassing Myspace account from 2007, to name a few. In one instance, an investigator followed the claimant he was surveilling into a bar. The pair sat down at the bar beside one another before speaking at length over a beer. The investigator asked the claimant about his employment, wherein he stated he was receiving worker’s compensation benefits. A few beers later, the claimant admitted the injury to his knee for which he was earning compensation was truly the result of a motorcycle accident years prior, not his job. The investigator later testified to this conversation in court and the claimant’s benefits were denied.[1] But in cases where workers are honestly suffering, the law permitting this type of monitoring poses a threat. For one, investigators may not always capture the whole story. They are tasked with one job only: find out if your claim is consistent with your injury. Photos and videos of your efforts to pick up groceries may not portray the seconds following, wherein you show signs of extreme pain. And who’s to say the information gathered from your ex-spouse—yet another way you can be surveilled—is accurate? Another issue with this law stems from an earlier stated statistic: most people don’t know that insurance companies can surveil them. Analogous to Connecticut and Delaware’s mandatory notification laws requiring employers to inform their employees about workplace monitoring practices, claimants should be clearly informed of insurance companies’ rights to surveil them. The potential harm of a fraudulent claimant showcasing their acting skills is greatly outweighed by injured workers attributing their feelings of being watched to something much more heinous than an insurance company. At the end of the day, worker’s compensation laws were not designed to keep money in the big man’s pocket; they exist to help employees recover from workplace-related incidents. No matter what, there will always be a bad apple abusing the system. But what must be realized is that when we make life more difficult for those we intend to serve, the bad apples are not the ones who suffer: it’s us.

[1] Hopper v. Indus. Comm’n, 27 Ariz. App. 732, 558 P.2d 927 (1976)

About the winner

Shaela Hayes

Shaela Hayes is an incoming senior at the University of Cincinnati, majoring in Legal and Ethical Philosophy, where she maintains a flawless academic record. While at UC, she has worked tirelessly to expand her knowledge of the law by interning with several diverse organizations, participating in victimology research, and holding various leadership roles. This upcoming spring, Shaela will continue her education in UC’s graduate school as she earns her graduate certificate in the Analysis of Criminal Behavior. Upon graduating in 2023, Shaela will also be awarded her ABA-approved Paralegal Studies Certificate and her Certificate in Forensic Populations before bringing her powerful passion for criminal defense to law school.

 

Thank you to everyone who participated in this college essay contest, and congratulations, Shaela, on your scholarship!
You can keep an eye out for future scholarship contests by visiting our scholarship page.

Related resources

  • Scholarships
    Scholarships
  • Vacation, PTO and Your Arizona Workers' Compensation Claim
    Vacation, PTO and Your Arizona Workers' Compensation Claim
  • Severe Burns and Explosion Injuries at Work in Arizona
    Severe Burns and Explosion Injuries at Work in Arizona
5-star review image
Went Above and Beyond
Workers Compensation  |  Phoenix
Went Above and Beyond
2019-07-16
"Dear Bob and Staff, this letter and gift is to express my sincere thanks for all you have ..."
K.J.S., Verified Customer
5-star review image
Exceptional service throughout
Workers Compensation  |  Phoenix
Workers' comp
2020-03-27
"I have worked with Bob for just over 3 years now and it has been exceptional service throughout. He ..."
C.C., Verified Customer
5-star review image
Many thanks to you and your staff!
Workers Compensation  |  Phoenix
Workers' comp
2020-03-27
"I was injured at work in 2009. Over my 10+ years of representation by Bob, I've had multiple surgeries and ..."
T. M., Verified Customer

Primary Sidebar

Categories

  • Community
  • Firm News
  • Work Injuries & Illnesses
  • Workers' Comp 101
  • Workers' Comp FAQs
  • Workplace Safety Tips

Recent Posts

  • The Law Offices of Robert E. Wisniewski Scholarship Winner: Insurance Surveillance of Injured Workers
  • Immigrant Workers and Their Rights, Documented or Not (Part 2)
  • Immigrant Workers and Their Rights, Documented or Not (Part 1)
  • Javier Grajeda Named a Southwest Super Lawyer Workers’ Compensation Rising Star

Footer

DISCUSS YOUR CASE WITH AN EXPERIENCED WORKERS' COMPENSATION LAWYER TODAY

CALL: (602) 234-3700
TOLL FREE IN AZ: (800) 224-3220
FAX: (602) 230-7579

Law office locations

Phoenix

519 E Thomas Rd
Phoenix, AZ 85012
Map and directions

Yuma

1455 W 16th St A2
Yuma, AZ 85364
Map and directions

    Get started with a free consultation

    Bilingual video consultations are available for your safety.

    Disclaimer: If you are not a current client of Law Offices of Robert E Wisniewski, PC, sending him or this site an email will not create an attorney/client relationship and the information you send may not be maintained as confidential. Please contact Mr. Wisniewski's office by telephone to arrange a consultation or complete a Consultation Intake Form. Viewing this website information also does not create an attorney/client relationship. This website is governed by the Arizona Rules of Professional Conduct.

    I have read the disclaimer.*
    Privacy Policy

    © 2023 Law Offices of Robert E. Wisniewski. All rights reserved. Disclaimer | Site Map | Law Firm Online Marketing by SEO Advantage, Inc.

    The Law Offices of Robert E. Wisniewski: Arizona Enjuris Partner Attorney

    • Facebook icon
    • Twitter icon
    • LinkedIn icon
    • Youtube icon