• Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer
Hurt on the Job? Call Bob in AZ

Hurt on the Job? Call Bob in AZ

"Justice for the injured worker"

602-234-3700
Call Today For A Free Initial Consultation
  • About Us
    • Attorneys
    • Meet the staff
    • Community
  • Workers’ Compensation
    • Benefits for injured workers
    • Am I eligible to apply?
    • My claim was denied.
    • Is PTSD covered?
    • Workers’ compensation guide
  • Work injuries
    • Back injury at work
    • Car accidents
    • Truck accidents
    • Traumatic brain injury
    • Shoulder injury
    • Slip and fall
    • View all
  • We Represent
    • Firefighters
    • Police
    • Paramedics
    • Professional Athletes
    • View all
  • Resources
    • Blog
    • Free Workers’ Comp E-book
    • Reviews
    • Videos
    • Scholarships
  • FAQ
  • Contact

Arizona Workers’ Compensation & Failed Drug Tests: What Happens Now?

Hurt on the Job? Call Bob, Arizona Work Injury Lawyer
phone icon (602) 234-3700 Schedule an Appointment
Phoenix Job Injury Attorney (Home) > Arizona's Worker's Compensation > Arizona Workers’ Compensation & Failed Drug Tests: What Happens Now?

Workers’ compensation eligibility for impaired workers and the role of drug testing

The premise of workers’ compensation is fairly straightforward. To protect the wellbeing of the workforce, the law in Arizona provides that employees should be compensated for work-related injuries. Thus, for a successful workers’ compensation claim to be approved, the injury must have related to the job.

For example, injuring one’s back while moving equipment for your employer constitutes a workplace injury. However, injuries that are unrelated to employment are not eligible for workers’ compensation benefits, even if they occurred at the workplace. For example, a heart attack unrelated to employment will not constitute a proper claim.

However, some injuries aren’t so clear-cut.

For example, a pre-existing condition can lead to an injury at the workplace from the strain or risk caused by the job. When an injury has multiple potential causes, such as when someone with an already weak back is further injured due to the strain of their job, a workers’ compensation claim can be challenged or denied.

employee drug testing rights Arizona

 

Another factor that can greatly complicate an Arizona workers’ compensation claim is if an injured worker’s drug test comes back positive.

How drug test and workers’ compensation claims were handled in the past

For many years, there has been ambiguity regarding whether or not workers’ compensation benefits are available to employees who were under the influence of drugs or alcohol and subsequently injured on the job. Historically, workers’ compensation insurers have required employees to submit to drug testing following a claim.

Generally, a positive drug test would result in a denial of the claim unless the injured worker is able to prove that the impairment did not contribute to the accident in question. Thus, this process had the effect of shifting the burden from the insurance company to the injured worker.

Given that the workers’ compensation program is designed to be a no-fault system, the denial of claims based upon the results of a drug test seemed facially inconsistent. Yet, because the process of drug testing workers was consistent with the public policy of keeping a workplace safe and drug-free, little action was taken to revise these standards for decades.

Further, because employers were often given discounts by their insurance companies for implementing drug testing programs, little incentive to change existed — until recently.

Impact of recent Supreme Court decisions on Arizona workers’ compensation benefits

The Arizona Constitution, as codified by A.R.S. § 23-1021(D), establishes that workers’ compensation is a constitutionally protected right. Thus, the previous pattern of denying workers’ compensation due to unrelated drug or alcohol use began to be questioned as unconstitutionally interfering with that right.

Two major cases led to the revision of drug testing as it relates to workers’ compensation claims.

Grammatico v. Industrial Commission

One case, Grammatico v. Industrial Commission, involved a construction worker who was injured after falling while using drywall stilts. In keeping with standard practice at the time, he was required to submit to drug testing before filing a claim. After he tested positive for numerous illegal substances, including methamphetamine and marijuana, his claim was denied.

The Supreme Court of Arizona found that Grammatico’s recreational drug use was not the primary cause of his injury. Because he had completed a large portion of the job in question without incident, his inevitable injury was only minutely caused by the substances in his system. Thus, because his employment as a drywaller was the primary cause of his injury, the court held that the denial of his claim was unconstitutional.

Komalestewa v. Industrial Commission

Another case, Komalestewa v. Industrial Commission, led to a similar result. The employee in question was injured by a conveyor belt and was later found to have had a trace amount of alcohol in his system. The Supreme Court held that, given the totality of the circumstances, the alcohol was not the primary cause of his injury. Thus, his claim should not have been denied.

 

 

 

 

 

Both of these cases establish a clear precedent that denying a workers’ compensation claim due solely to a worker’s intoxication or drug use is inconsistent with the intent and practical application of the laws and constitution of Arizona.

Can your employer drug test you following a workplace incident?

Simply put, yes.

The above-mentioned cases did not rule that drug or alcohol testing was unconstitutional. Rather, they simply made it unlawful for workers’ compensation insurance companies to deny a claim simply because someone tested positive for an impairing substance in Arizona.

Previously, workers’ compensation claims required an analysis of the “primary cause” of the injury. The “primary cause” analysis sought to assign fault, either to the employer or, more often, the employee. Yet, workers’ compensation is designed specifically to be a no-fault system.

A workplace injury involving drugs or alcohol should be handled no differently than any other claim. As long as it can be shown that the nature of your employment contributed to your injury in some way, your claim for benefits should be approved.

However, it should be noted that these cases have no bearing on a worker’s relationship with their employer. An employee’s drug testing rights in Arizona applies only to workers’ compensation; it doesn’t protect your employment. Thus, a worker who fails a drug test can still be terminated, whether or not the test followed a workplace injury.

Injured on the Job? Read Arizona Workers’ Compensation FAQ


Injured on the Job? Read Arizona Workers’ Compensation FAQ

Questions and answers about compensation for a job-related accident, injury or illness in Arizona

Find out more

Consult an experienced Arizona workers’ compensation attorney

If you or a loved one were hurt on the job, you’ll want an experienced lawyer on your side fighting for your rights. For Arizona workers, this means contacting the Law Offices of Robert E. Wisniewski.

Contact us today for your free consultation.

Related resources

  • How Does Arizona Workers’ Comp Work?
    How Does Arizona Workers’ Comp Work?
  • Guide to Arizona Workers’ Rights When Injured on the Job
    Guide to Arizona Workers’ Rights When Injured on the Job
  • Immigrant Workers and Their Rights, Documented or Not (Part 1)
    Immigrant Workers and Their Rights, Documented or Not (Part…

Footer

DISCUSS YOUR CASE WITH AN EXPERIENCED WORKERS' COMPENSATION LAWYER TODAY

CALL: (602) 234-3700
TOLL FREE IN AZ: (800) 224-3220
FAX: (602) 230-7579

Law office locations

Phoenix

519 E Thomas Rd
Phoenix, AZ 85012
Map and directions

Yuma

1455 W 16th St A2
Yuma, AZ 85364
Map and directions

    Get started with a free consultation

    Bilingual video consultations are available for your safety.

    Disclaimer: If you are not a current client of Law Offices of Robert E Wisniewski, PC, sending him or this site an email will not create an attorney/client relationship and the information you send may not be maintained as confidential. Please contact Mr. Wisniewski's office by telephone to arrange a consultation or complete a Consultation Intake Form. Viewing this website information also does not create an attorney/client relationship. This website is governed by the Arizona Rules of Professional Conduct.

    I have read the disclaimer.*
    Privacy Policy

    © 2023 Law Offices of Robert E. Wisniewski. All rights reserved. Disclaimer | Site Map | Law Firm Online Marketing by SEO Advantage, Inc.

    The Law Offices of Robert E. Wisniewski: Arizona Enjuris Partner Attorney

    • Facebook icon
    • Twitter icon
    • LinkedIn icon
    • Youtube icon